Yes. That distinction is enormous because it changes the entire direction of the Christian life.
If my conduct creates the relationship, then every day I am trying to move God toward me.
If my conduct proceeds from an already-established relationship, then every day I am learning to live out what God has already given me in Christ.
Those may sometimes produce similar outward actionsβprayer, obedience, repentance, serviceβbut inwardly they are radically different worlds.
πΏ Creating a relationship versus living from one
Think of the difference this way.
If I believe my conduct continually creates my relationship with God, my inner logic becomes:
I obey β therefore God accepts me.
I pray β therefore God comes near.
I perform well β therefore God is pleased to have me.
I fail β therefore the relationship itself is endangered.
I repent β therefore perhaps God will receive me again.
The whole relationship rests precariously upon my present spiritual condition.
But the gospel reverses the direction:
God chose and called me β therefore I respond.
God justified me β therefore I stand in grace.
God adopted me β therefore I learn to live as His child.
God gave me His Spirit β therefore I can walk in newness of life.
God united me to Christ β therefore His life increasingly appears in me.
Paul captures this order beautifully:
“For you are all sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus.”
β Galatians 3:26
And then:
“And because you are sons, God has sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying out, ‘Abba, Father!'”
β Galatians 4:6
Notice the order:
Because you are sons.
Not:
Behave sufficiently like sons so that God may eventually make you sons.
The relationship precedes the life that grows from it.
π “Settled” does not mean static
This is where we need an important distinction.
Our relationship with God can be settled while our fellowship with Him can vary tremendously.
A child may disobey his father. Something real happens.
Trust can be affected.
Joy can be diminished.
Correction may be necessary.
The child may hide.
The father may discipline.
Reconciliation at the level of fellowship may be needed.
But the child has not thereby become a stranger.
This is very close to what John describes. He writes to people who already belong to God, yet tells them:
“If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.”
β 1 John 1:9
And shortly afterward:
“My little children, these things I write to you, so that you may not sin.”
β 1 John 2:1
They are “little children” even while John addresses the possibility of their sin.
So settled relationship does not make sin inconsequential.
Rather, it determines how sin is dealt with.
It is dealt with inside the Father’s house.
β€οΈ The Cross is what makes the relationship settled
This is where everything rests.
If God’s acceptance of me ultimately depended upon the quality of today’s obedience, the relationship could never really be settled.
There would always be another evaluation tomorrow.
But Paul says:
“Therefore, having been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ.”
β Romans 5:1
And:
“There is therefore now no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus.”
β Romans 8:1
The foundation is outside us.
Christ has accomplished something.
This is why the security is not psychological optimism about ourselves. It is confidence in the sufficiency of Someone else.
My spiritual temperature changes.
Christ’s finished work does not.
My obedience varies.
Christ’s righteousness does not.
My awareness of God’s love fluctuates.
God’s action toward me in His Son does not have to be reconstructed every morning.
“For by one offering He has perfected forever those who are being sanctified.”
β Hebrews 10:14
That verse contains the tension wonderfully:
“perfected forever”
and
“being sanctified.”
Something is settled.
Something is still happening.
π± This completely changes sanctification
Without a settled relationship, sanctification easily becomes an attempt to secure belonging.
With a settled relationship, sanctification becomes learning to live according to belonging.
Paul’s letters constantly work this way.
He tells the Colossians:
“For you died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God.”
β Colossians 3:3
Then he says:
“Therefore put to death your members which are on the earth…”
β Colossians 3:5
That “therefore” is everything.
He doesn’t say:
Put sin to death so that someday your life may become hidden with Christ in God.
He says:
Your life is hidden with Christ in God; therefore let your conduct correspond to that reality.
The imperative grows out of the indicative.
What God has done becomes the ground of what we are called to do.
ποΈ It also changes repentance
This may be one of the most beautiful implications.
If the relationship depends upon my performance, failure makes me want to hide.
That is Adam:
“I was afraid… and I hid myself.”
β Genesis 3:10
But if my relationship with the Father rests upon Christ, failure should eventually move me in the opposite direction:
toward Him.
“Let us therefore come boldly to the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy and find grace to help in time of need.”
β Hebrews 4:16
Think about how remarkable that is.
Our need does not disqualify us from approaching the throne.
Our need is precisely why we approach it.
This does not produce casual repentance. It can actually produce much deeper repentance because I no longer have to spend my energy protecting myself from God.
I can say:
“Father, I sinned.”
without simultaneously wondering:
“Have I destroyed everything?”
The Cross has already answered the larger question.
π It changes prayer too
Prayer is no longer trying to persuade a distant God to establish a relationship with me.
Jesus says:
“When you pray, say:
Our Father…”
β Luke 11:2
That first phrase changes everything that follows.
I don’t pray my way into sonship.
I pray from sonship.
And Paul goes even further:
“God has sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying out, ‘Abba, Father!'”
β Galatians 4:6
Even our cry toward the Father is produced by the Spirit of the Son within us.
Prayer becomes participation in a relationship God Himself has established.
π‘οΈ It changes how we experience failure
If today’s performance determines whether God remains Father, then every failure becomes potentially catastrophic.
We begin constantly examining ourselves:
“Did I pray enough?”
“Was my repentance sincere enough?”
“Was my faith strong enough?”
“Did I disappoint God too badly?”
“Am I still accepted?”
There is certainly a biblical place for self-examination (2 Corinthians 13:5; 1 Corinthians 11:28). But there is a form of introspection that becomes spiritually suffocating because we keep looking inside ourselves for the stability that exists only in Christ.
Paul’s answer is breathtakingly external:
“Who shall bring a charge against God’s elect? It is God who justifies.”
β Romans 8:33
My ultimate security is not:
“I have examined myself and found myself satisfactory.”
It is:
“God justifies.”
π¨βπ§ And discipline itself changes meaning
This connects directly with what we were discussing.
If the relationship is unsettled, discipline can feel like:
“Perhaps God is getting ready to throw me out.”
But Hebrews says almost exactly the opposite:
“For whom the LORD loves He chastens…”
β Hebrews 12:6
And:
“God deals with you as with sons.”
β Hebrews 12:7
Discipline occurs because the relationship exists.
The Father’s correction isn’t the opposite of adoption.
It is one of its consequences.
He corrects us because He is committed to making His children increasingly resemble His Son (Romans 8:29; Hebrews 12:10β11).
π₯ And strangely, security makes obedience more serious, not less
This is the objection that naturally arises:
“If the relationship is settled, won’t people become careless?”
Paul encountered essentially that objection:
“Shall we continue in sin that grace may abound?”
β Romans 6:1
His answer is not:
“Yes, because your behavior doesn’t matter.”
Nor does he respond:
“Then perhaps grace isn’t really secure.”
He says:
“Certainly not! How shall we who died to sin live any longer in it?”
β Romans 6:2
Again, identity precedes conduct.
Grace doesn’t say:
“Sin doesn’t matter.”
Grace says:
“Sin no longer fits who you are.”
That can actually make sin more grievous.
I am not merely breaking an external regulation.
I am behaving contrary to the life God has given me.
π³ Jesus gives us perhaps the clearest picture: the vine
“Abide in Me, and I in you.”
β John 15:4
A branch doesn’t bear fruit in order to attach itself to the vine.
It bears fruit because it is attached to the vine.
That distinction is enormous.
Imagine a branch lying on the ground saying:
“If I can just produce enough grapes, perhaps I can convince the vine to accept me.”
Impossible.
Life must come first.
Then fruit.
Jesus says:
“He who abides in Me, and I in him, bears much fruit; for without Me you can do nothing.”
β John 15:5
So Christian fruitfulness isn’t fundamentally production for acceptance.
It is life expressing itself through union.
And this connects beautifully with what we have been discussing about responsibility and sovereignty.
Even my sanctification is not a private construction project in which God hands me salvation and says, “Now make something of yourself.”
It remains a life of dependence:
“For it is God who works in you both to will and to do for His good pleasure.”
β Philippians 2:13
Yet immediately before that Paul tells us to:
“work out your own salvation with fear and trembling.”
β Philippians 2:12
There again are responsibility and sovereignty in their proper places.
We work because God works in us.
π
And this profoundly changes tomorrow
This returns us to the sentence that started our previous reflection:
“Your Father will still be Father tomorrow.”
If the relationship had to be recreated every day by my conduct, tomorrow would be terrifying.
I would wake up spiritually homeless every morning and have to earn my way back into the house.
But the gospel says something entirely different.
I wake up in Christ.
“Your life is hidden with Christ in God.”
β Colossians 3:3
I wake up adopted.
“You received the Spirit of adoption by whom we cry out, ‘Abba, Father.'”
β Romans 8:15
I wake up with access.
“Through Him we both have access by one Spirit to the Father.”
β Ephesians 2:18
I wake up under grace.
“We have access by faith into this grace in which we stand.”
β Romans 5:2
And therefore the fundamental question of the day is no longer:
“What must I accomplish today so that God will be my Father tonight?”
It becomes:
“Father, since I am Yours, how shall I live with You today?”
That is an entirely different Christian life.
And perhaps the deepest implication is this: a settled relationship frees us to concentrate on the relationship itself.
I no longer need to spend all my time negotiating whether I belong.
Now I can actually know the Father.
Love Him.
Listen to Him.
Obey Him.
Be corrected by Him.
Depend upon Him.
Enjoy Him.
Return to Him when I fall.
Become increasingly like His Son.
The gospel does not make relationship with God less serious by settling our acceptance in Christ. It finally makes genuine relationship possible, because we are no longer approaching God primarily as defendants awaiting another verdict, but as children coming to the Father through the Son.
“And truly our fellowship is with the Father and with His Son Jesus Christ.”
β 1 John 1:3
The verdict has been rendered in Christ.
Now comes the life with God.