Yes — absolutely.
And this is one of the most striking, unsettling, and beautiful truths in Scripture:
Mistreating an image-bearer is an insult to God regardless of that person’s holiness or sinfulness.
Human righteousness or sin does not add to or subtract from the value God has placed on His image.
The dignity comes from God’s imprint, not the person’s behavior.
Let’s walk through this with clarity and depth.
🌟 1. The Image of God Is Not Lost Through Sin
After the fall, even though humanity became corrupted, God still refers to humans as bearing His image.
Look at Genesis 9:6 — spoken long after Eden:
“Whoever sheds man’s blood… for in the image of God He made man.”
This is after:
- the fall,
- Cain’s murder,
- the wickedness of the world,
- the flood.
Yet God still says: in the image of God.
Sin distorts the image, but it does not erase it.
🔥 2. God Defends Even the Wicked From Unjust Treatment
This is almost shocking when we first see it.
For example, God forbids gloating over the fall of an enemy:
“Do not rejoice when your enemy falls.”
(Proverbs 24:17)
He forbids taking vengeance or bearing grudges:
“You shall not take vengeance… but you shall love your neighbor.”
(Leviticus 19:18)
He protects even criminals from degrading punishment:
- No beating a man more than 40 stripes (Deuteronomy 25:3).
- No mutilating offenders (a common ancient practice).
- No withholding basic dignity even from someone being executed.
Why?
Because the offender is still an image-bearer.
Their value is not canceled by their sin.
🩸 3. Even the Most Corrupt Still Touch God’s Heart as His Creation
Think of Jonah 4:11 — God speaks of wicked Nineveh:
“Should I not pity Nineveh, that great city…?”
These were violent, brutal, oppressive people.
Yet God’s compassion is stirred by the fact that they are His creatures, bearing His imprint, and spiritually blind.
God’s pity rests on them not because they are righteous, but because they are His.
🪞 4. Mistreating a Sinner Is Still a Reproach to God
Proverbs 14:31 teaches:
“He who oppresses the poor reproaches his Maker.”
But this principle extends beyond the poor and beyond holiness.
Because the foundation of the command is the Maker, not the moral state of the person.
When Moses struck the Egyptian who was harming a Hebrew, even that was morally complex — the Egyptian, though doing wrong, was still a human being.
God does not approve harming someone simply because they are sinful.
He alone holds the right to judge perfectly.
🕊️ 5. Jesus Models This:
Jesus treats:
- tax collectors,
- prostitutes,
- violent zealots,
- Pharisees,
- adulterers,
- demon-possessed men,
- Roman executioners
with dignity, patience, compassion, or at minimum, justice.
Even when He rebukes the Pharisees harshly, He never dehumanizes them.
His strongest condemnations target hypocrisy, not their image-bearing identity.
And when He is dying, what does He say?
“Father, forgive them.”
(Luke 23:34)
Those executing Him are not righteous — far from it — yet He views them still as image-bearers needing mercy.
🌈 6. Why This Matters
Because it means:
- A godly person wronged is an affront to God.
- A sinful person wronged is an affront to God.
- A stranger wronged is an affront to God.
- An enemy wronged is an affront to God.
- A vulnerable person wronged is an affront to God.
- A criminal wronged beyond justice is an affront to God.
The value comes from God’s imprint — not the person’s moral state.
Holiness enhances fellowship with God,
but does not increase a person’s intrinsic worth as His image-bearer.
Sin breaks relationship with God,
but does not decrease a person’s intrinsic dignity as His image-bearer.
🌿 7. So Yes — The Image Is Independent of Behavior
Mistreat anyone — righteous or wicked — and you dishonor God.
Bless anyone — righteous or wicked — and you honor God.
And this is precisely why Jesus commands:
“Love your enemies.”
(Matthew 5:44)
Because their enmity does not cancel God’s likeness in them.