That disconnect is one of the most mysterious and sobering realities in Scripture — and it appears again and again in Israel’s history, in the Gospels, and even in the Church today. Let’s unfold it gently, because it reveals something deep about the human heart.
They Accepted the Content but Resisted the Speaker
A person can admire Scripture, defend it, memorize it, quote it, and even build a system of life around it — yet avoid the living God who is addressing them through it.
It’s the difference between:
- knowing someone’s letters
- and actually knowing the person who wrote them
The Pharisees illustrate this perfectly. They believed in the authority of the text, loved the text, studied the text, and yet Jesus said:
John 5:39-40
You search the Scriptures… but you are not willing to come to Me that you may have life.
The problem wasn’t with Scripture.
The problem was with their refusal to meet the God Scripture pointed to.
Why Does This Happen?
Because the heart can prefer control over relationship.
Scripture as text can be held at arm’s length.
Scripture as God’s voice comes too close.
When God speaks:
- He confronts pride
- He exposes motives
- He calls for surrender
- He reveals that He is King, not us
Many people want the information of Scripture without the interruption of God Himself.
They Loved the Form, Not the Face
Paul describes this perfectly:
2 Timothy 3:5
Having a form of godliness but denying its power.
Form = Scripture, rituals, doctrines, traditions
Power = the living God who speaks, convicts, saves, transforms
The disconnect occurs when someone embraces the form but resists the power.
They Treated Scripture as an Object, Not a Voice
Jesus said something astonishing:
Matthew 22:31
Have you not read what was spoken to you by God…?
Notice the paradox:
“What you read was spoken to you.”
That means Scripture is not a static text.
It is a living address from a speaking God.
You can study the grammar and miss the Speaker.
You can dissect the sentence and ignore the call.
You can defend the doctrine and avoid the encounter.
They Wanted God to Fit Their System
This is exactly what happened with the religious leaders in Jesus’ day. They believed Scripture — but only their interpretation of it.
When God appeared in front of them:
- humbly
- mercifully
- powerfully
- incarnate
He did not fit their expectations, so they rejected Him.
John 1:11
He came to His own, and His own did not receive Him.
They loved the idea of God more than the reality of God.
They Could Not Accept That God Was Present
This is the ultimate disconnect:
- They believed what God had said
- They did not believe what God was saying
Jesus repeatedly said:
Matthew 23:24
You blind guides…
Luke 19:44
You did not know the time of your visitation.
Their theology was technically correct.
Their hearts were spiritually closed.
At the Core, It Is a Relational Failure
Faith is fundamentally relational — trust, surrender, nearness, listening, responding.
But Scripture without relationship becomes:
- information without transformation
- law without life
- doctrine without devotion
- truth without trust
- words without the Word
This is why Jesus could say to people who knew Scripture better than anyone:
John 8:47
He who is of God hears God’s words.
The issue was not literacy, but receptivity.
So What Is This Disconnect?
It is when a person:
- engages Scripture but avoids God
- accepts facts but rejects intimacy
- likes the idea of truth but resists obedience
- wants certainty but not surrender
- handles the Bible as a book but not as a voice
- studies revelation while refusing relationship
It is the tragedy of hearing God without hearing Him.